Welcome to my world!

Larry Hayes

Larry Hayes

I’m the retired editorial page editor and columnist for the Fort Wayne Journal Gazette, a former minister, high school and college instructor and activist.  I’m the author of Mental Illness and Your Town and Monday I’ll Save the World. My expertise lies in such fields as mental health and mental illness, juvenile justice,  education, racial justice and poverty.   As a rule, I’ll use current news items to launch my comments

Where gay kids hurt

Let me be clear:  No gay or lesbian kid should be bullied, harassed or made to feel disrespected and rejected.   No gay or lesbian kid.  None, period.

Yet rejection is the very thing that seems to be the experience of gay and lesbian teenagers in the most politically conservative communities.  What other explanation can you offer for the finding of Columbia University researchers of the high incidence of suicide attempts in such Oregon counties?

The researchers surveyed about 32,000 high school students throughout that state.  Here’s what those kids told them.   In mostly Republican conservative counties, where few Democrats live, about 20 percent of gay and lesbian kids said they had attempted suicide at least once.

At the same time, only 4 percent of straight kids in these communities reported making a suicide attempt.    Which would be the story for gay and straight kids in mainly Democratic counties.

You can read all about it in the current issue of the journal Pediatrics.

Thank goodness, my son, who is straight,  survived four suicide attempts as a teenager.   So our family has had some experience in the trauma of an attempt.   Such events cast a shadow over our family for years.  It’s hard to imagine what losing a child to suicide would do to one’s sense of personal security.  When would you stop grieving?

The Columbia researchers note that the suicide attempts for the gay and lesbian kids in the study occurred whether or not they were bullied or depressed.

In conservative communities, you’re not likely to find school programs that support gay and lesbian kids.  In more progressive communities, such programs are common.  Further, those kids will find support in the mainline churches.  Straight kids here will befriend them, take their side and be their advocate.

Our granddaughter, a university student, has one gay friend whose family lives in a conservative town north of our city.  He fears to tell his parents.  He believes that if he told them that he’s gay, they would be devastated. Maybe even reject him.

Where does such prejudice come from?  What does a rejection of anyone on the basis of sexual orientation have to do with politics? What does it have to do with religion?

Clearly, many young gay and lesbian people internalize the bigotry they hear voiced at the dinner table, from the pulpit and from the most conservative politicians.  Growing up amid the expression of such self-righteous and ignorant attitudes becomes a burden no child should have to bear.

How is it that you don’t find such bigotry directed toward adulterers or those who divorce? I point out that such things seem to be condemned in sacred texts.

Oddly enough, the same holy scriptures that are interpreted  to condemn deviations from the sexual norm also condemn those who would judge others.  Instead, these scriptures call upon us to love and accept everyone.

Homophobia seems to be a special, even unique form of bigotry.   And like most all prejudices, it can have terrible, tragic consequences.  The Columbia University study merely tells us where you’re most likely to find it.

When M*A*S*H* came to town

Okay.  It wasn’t the entire cast, Hawkeye, Radar, Hot Lips, Major Burns and Col. Potter.   But B.J. Hunnicut showed up.  For me, it was enough to have the actor/activist Mike Farrell make an appearance, ably representing the entire cast of the 4077.  It was my favorite TV show.

I met Mike and heard him speak on the death penalty at Beacon Heights Church of the Brethren, a member of one of the three historic peace churches.

When he arrived, he was still wearing in navy topcoat, his wavy hair turned mostly white since his earlier days in the popular TV series.  Yet he’s as handsome as that young, war-weary captain, with a friendly, disarming manner.   He seemed eager on this bitter cold morning to get on with the session.

The church gradually filled, with many faces I recognized from my visits over the years and of other friends I came to know during my time writing editorials, dozens against the death penalty.

Ellen Eggers, a California death penalty attorney originally from Fort Wayne, led the speakers.  She told a sad, even tragic story.  Lots of people don’t know that over two thirds of the countries have abolished the death penalty.   But that fits with how we treat all offenders, from the small-time drug dealers to murderers.  In face, we now lock up more people than any country in the world, even China which has four times the U.S. population.

Such punishment hasn’t made us safer, when we’re compared to other democracies.   In fact, as Eggers pointed out, the death penalty is an illusion.  It doesn’t deter murder.  There’s plenty of research on that.  And it doesn’t bring healing to the victims’ survivors.  That’s been my own observation.

Because of the lengthy appeals, and the cost of housing a capital offender, the death penalty costs the taxpayer far more than giving the person a life sentence.   Death row is not bargain:  A regular cell can run as high as $50,000 a year.  The solitary cell on death row  can cost more than $90,000.  Even conservative Indiana’s attorney general, Greg Zoeller, has challenged lawmakers here to weigh the value of executions in light of the cost.  Nationwide, we have 3,000 people in those cells today.   About half, it’s estimated, are mentally ill.   Which was true of every case I wrote about.

Rachel Gross followed Eggers.  A long-time friend from North Manchester, Rachel told stories of her network of people who write letters and send cards to death row inmates.    Some of these letter-writers have visited with the offenders, offering friendship and human contact with a person not part of the criminal justice machine.

Mike Farrell knows his message backwards and forwards, no need for notes or a script.  I thought it was noteworthy that he encouraged death penalty abolitionists not to become self-righteous.  I’ve probably been guilty of that myself.  But to the substance of the issue, citing Justice John Paul Stevens’ recent article, Mike argued that an execution can’t be done constitutionally.

It’s the poor, the minority defendant who is the most likely to receive a death sentence.  As one study of Georgia cases showed, a black defendant is 11 times more likely than a white defendant to get the death penalty. And it’s used disproportionately throughout the country. Several states don’t even have the death penalty on the books.  Most states that do have a higher capital crime rate.

When it’s invoked, the sentence is carried out freakishly, like being struck by lightening.  I imagine Mike, given his role in M*A*S*H*, must often have thought that such punishment is  about as senseless and arbitrary as the battle deaths in Korea.

But he suggested a constructive approach for abolitionists to defenders of the death penalty.  Rather than argue that killing somebody already locked up in a cage is immoral, show how there’s no way that death penalty can be administered fairly.  Impossible, which is exactly where Justice Stevens finished his long tenure on the high court.

Moreover, Mike concluded, such an extreme, inhumane punishment corrodes our system of justice and corrupts those who join in this legalized murder.  And as we’ve dehumanized the offender, we dehumanize the rest of us.  It’s real simple he said:

“Everybody counts or nobody counts.”

The Price to Punish

I was seated at the banquet next to Marvin Wolfgang.

We were attending a conference at the University of Pennsylvania on juvenile justice.   Many of the country’s top experts showed up, along with two journalists, Fox Butterfield of The New York Times and me, then the editorial page editor for the Fort Wayne Journal Gazette.

I don’t recall the names of most people there.  But Professor Wolfgang would have stood out in any such gathering.  And if you got to visit with him, you sure wouldn’t forget.  He’s still regarded one of the most influential criminologists of all time.

I was reminded of that evening in the mid-1990s by a recent news story in The Journal Gazette. It told about a hearing of state policy makers.  The panel took up the subject of the Indiana Department of Correction budget. Commissioner Ed Buss spoke.

He’s been watching his budget balloon every year.  By 2014, he projects that feeding and housing inmates will cost $675.2 million.  That would be up from the projected $667.4 million in 2012.

It’s not that the commissioner has been feeding inmates steak every day.  He’s already cut 1,000 staff jobs in recent years.  But the demands to house more and more prisoners grows every year – about 1,000 in fact.   Does Indiana  have more crime?   Not at all.  We don’t have less crime, either.

What’s happened is that over the past 20 years, as Commissioner Buss notes, the legislature has added 107 new crimes.  Further, lawmakers keep tacking on longer sentences to existing crimes.  We all know why:  Politicians want people to believe they’re getting “tough on crime.”

Of course, tough on crime isn’t the same thing as getting smart on crime.  Which brings me back to the eminent criminologist, Professor Wolfgang.

“Do longer sentences really reduce crime?”

My dinner companion smiled and shook his head.

“No,” he said.

Then he turned away from the salad to more fully answer my question.

“To the contrary.”

“The longer somebody is locked up, the more likely they’ll commit more crime when they’re released.”

I’d come across research to that effect before.  But so directly from the professor made it a more powerful conclusion than ever.

In his testimony the other day, Indiana’s DOC’s commissioner called for an overhaul of sentencing.  Yet he noted that it would take a lot of courage from lawmakers to move away from the draconian sentences now regularly being meted out.

We could cut the length of sentences.  We could put more inmates into community corrections, at a much lower cost than in prison.  (The state currently houses more than 3,000 nonviolent offenders who would pose no threat to their towns.)  We could give more time off the sentences for good behavior.

One state lawmaker at the hearing seemed to discount any of these changes ever happening  ”It would take a lot of guts,” he pointed out, echoing the commissioner’s words.

But the changes would only take guts if legislators believe that longer sentences in prison reduce crime. Trouble with that belief is that for all these people locked up for longer periods,  crime hasn’t gone down.  In fact, in some categories, such as assault and property crimes, we’ve seen more crime.

What about acting on Professor Wolfgang’s research and the findings of other experts?   What if reducing time in prison for most felons actually reduced crime?   We don’t even have to  try a pilot program to test the proposition.  Shorter sentences work well for countries in Western Europe, which report far less crime than we do in this country.

I know Commissioner Buss worries about his budget and the cost of handing out longer sentences to more offenders.  Taking a page from the professor, I believe state leaders can rightly tell their constituents that they’ll support an overhaul of sentencing.  It won’t be just to save money .  It will protect the public safety.

Our wonderful melting pot

“America is the greatest country in the world, she said.”

That was U.S. District Judge Theresa L. Springmann.

Seated between the U.S. and Indiana flags,  she was addressing the 54 persons from 23 different countries who were being sworn in that morning as America’s newest citizens.

This past week, I wasn’t so sure we were the greatest country.

According to polls, most Americans oppose the construction of an Islamic community center near Ground Zero.  Even the usually broad-minded New Yorkers don’t like the center near the site.

I caught a distinct whiff of bigotry directed at Muslims when I first heard of the opposition.    Hey, I wanted to shout.  Muslims didn’t bring down the World Trade Center.   That was suicidal fanatics.

Never mind the First Amendment, all that beautiful rhetoric about tolerance, respect for everyone regardless of race, religion or national origin.   Cable TV’s talking heads grumbled and  the next thing you knew lots of folks talked as if the Commies had crawled under our beds again.

I refuse to dwell on the weird case of the Rev. Terry Jones and his tiny Gainesville church that planned to burn copies of the Koran on 9/11.   Too much has been said about that already.

In any case, those few days didn’t seem to  be a good week for proclaiming our country’s greatness.   Until that Friday morning in a a federal courtroom.   Just think about.  More than 50 people from all over the world sworn in as American citizens.  That included our good friend Abdalla from Darfur.   Well, observing all this I had to conclude that I  Judge Springmann is right. We are pretty great.  Never mind the nut cases.

What other country attracts such a diverse group of immigrants?   What other country really does accommodate most all the time such a diversity?   Even Fort Wayne schools here in the traditionalist heartland provide special help for kids who grew up speaking a score of other languages.

The judge reminded the audience of all the things our newest citizens had to do to win their U.S. citizenship.  That took years of study, including English language lessons and American history.  They had to go through a background check.  And a personal interview.   It all took courage, she said.

They have to swear allegiance to the country, even bear arms if only as a non-combatant.   (I was glad to even pacifists can become naturalized citizens.)  What about giving those millions of undocumented a shot at this, too?

Many native born citizens might have trouble making the cut.  What year did the Civil War end?  Who were we fighting in the Korean War?  What president introduced Social Security?  Get out your U.S. history books you native born!

“You dared to dream the American dream,” Judge Springmann said, again to the new citizens.   That line hit a chord with me.  Gave me chills.   That’s right.  We’re truly a land of dreamers.

The judge even made the ceremony personal.  In her concluding remarks, she told us that her own grandparents had come to America as immigrants.  She spoke of their dreams, their hopes, their struggles and the life they made for their descendants: doctors, teachers, business leaders and, yes, a judge.   Immigrants bring such gifts, making our mosaic much more dazzling.

We all stood for the pledge of allegiance.  Then we sang the Star Spangled Banner.   You wouldn’t want to make a CD of that rendition of the national anthem, accompanied by a recording.   But it was sung in earnest in a dozen accents.   Beautiful.

At the closing,  Judge Springmann invited the new citizens to join her at the judge’s bench, front of the riblue drape with the U.S. district court of Northern Indiana seal on it.  She wanted to shake hands of these newly honored Americans and give them a chance to have their pictures taken.

At the insistence of our friend Abdalla, my wife and I joined him, his wife, daughter, two sons  and the judge for the photo opportunity.  And we all celebrated this milestone.

As we made our way to the door, I glanced at the photographs of the judges who had presided over this courtroom.  Faces I recognized from my days with the paper looked back.   There were others from long ago, before my journalism career.  Lots of heartwarming stories unfolded under that vaulted ceiling.

The ceremony is held once a month, a court official told me.  But he thought it was going to be changed to once every other month.  He didn’t say why.

You don’t think much about how so many different seasonings get dropped into our melting pot every month, all across the country, in every state.   If you’re amazed at the rapid change in technology, consider the change in the makeup of the population.

They escaped from El Salvador’s civil war.  They fled oppression in Burma.  They left loved ones in India for new opportunities here.  They gave up the grinding poverty of Haiti.   They brought with them their beliefs, their customs, their work ethic.  And probably some prejudices, too.

Witnessing this profoundly moving ceremony,  I knew our home-grown bigots won’t carry the day.   Eventually, they’ll get their comeuppance and fade away.  And the rest of us will move on.   Conceived in liberty, one nation.  Because that’s who we are.

Deficit Delusions

“I just can’t get my head around it.”

Dave was talking about the trillion dollar deficit.

He blames Obama.

Well, he wasn’t happy with Bush, either.

He was against invading Iraq. Yes, he was even against invading Afghanistan, although – he grants – the Taliban had been harboring Islamic terrorists. He knows that was all Bush’s doing.

For the moment, though, Dave is chiefly upset with Obama and all the money that’s been spent bailing out Wall Street and the auto industry.

In Dave’s defense, I should point out that he spent his career as a social worker. He remains a great champion of kids and has no patience with those who want to take kids who commit crimes, lock ‘em up and throw away the key. He’s not indifferent to people who are suffering in this recession.

Besides, he’s an old friend from high school. We share the same birthday.

But his anger over the deficit echoes the Tea Party movement. I guess if there’s one issue that unites folk who identify with that group it’s the deficit spending. To be sure, they don’t like the health care reform law, either.

I recall that for most of the years I wrote editorials for The Journal Gazette in Fort Wayne – nearly 30 – the federal government ran a deficit. During the Johnson years, the deficit financed the Great Society programs and the Vietnam War. Nixon ran up deficits. So did Ford. And Carter. Yes, Reagan and Bush I. It wasn’t until Clinton that the feds gave us a surplus. The second Bush quickly spent that, thanks in part to large tax cuts for higher income citizens.

Everybody hates deficit spending.

How often do you hear these days, “Why if I ran my household the way the president – you name him – runs the federal government, I’d be in the poorhouse”?

The truth is that most Americans, at one time or another, do run up deficits. Granted, not on the scale of the federal government. Car payments, credit card interest and mortgages – these aren’t tiddly-winks. Those represent deficit spending.

We go into debt to buy what we think we need and, under the normal rules of the game, we can show our creditors that we’ll be able to pay off the debt.

In the deepest recession since the Great Depression, the government would be incredibly irresponsible not to run up the deficit. Indeed, the huge amount of spending that Dave – and I suppose most of us – can’t get our heads around has helped prevent an even deeper recession. In fact, we seem to be emerging from the economic crisis. In some parts of the country, unemployment seems to be inching back down. Other signs show improvement.

According to the Treasure Department, the deficit in June 2010 dropped to $68.4 billion. That’s down from $94.3 billion last June.

That’s impressive. But it’s pretty simple math.

As more people go back to work, they start paying taxes again. So the government collects more money and the deficit falls. Obviously, you want to see those big numbers whittled much further. That’s the challenge once we’re really out of the recession. For now, there’s plenty to debate about how federal dollars should be spent to prop up the economy. But the reality is, deficit spending probably has been our country’s salvation.

Bill Taylor

An old friend died the other day.

Bill Taylor wasn’t just anybody either.  Not to me.  Not to the country.

Indeed, his obit ran in The New York Times and other major newspapers.

They told how he was a major civil rights attorney, starting his career with Thurgood Marshall, then head of the NAACP Legal Defense and Educational Fund.

Attorneys there had this brilliant young lawyer write the legal brief in the Little Rock desegregation case.

He was the lead attorney in a number of cases, including St. Louis.  And in Cincinnati.

“I wish we could clone him,” Federal District Judge Walter Rice in that case told me.

I got to know Bill when I was writing editorials that called for Fort Wayne Community Schools to fully desegregate its kids.  That was in the 1970s and 1980s.  The district ran half dozen schools that we nearly all black in our inner city.   Bill, mostly by telephone, tutored me in the fine points of desegregation law, the history of major court decisions and the legal basis of any suit we could file against the district here.

I got to know Bill best at education conferences and, when my wife Toni was a program officer at the National Science Foundation in 1992, over a number of lunches.

I helped enlist Bill to lead the effort to get the Fort Wayne district to do what I strongly felt was its legal and moral responsibility.   With the financial support of Lincoln National Corp.’s CEO, Ian Rolland, Bill got involved.  First, he tried negotiations with school attorneys.  That produced only frustration.  Then, in 1986, he filed the lawsuit in federal court.   It wasn’t until 1989, however, that district officials consented to an out-of-court settlement.

The result was to racially balance all Fort Wayne schools, mostly by creating a number of magnet schools.

That watershed event in the community’s history now seems so long ago.  You no longer see letters to the editor decrying the integration of the schools.  Nobody even proposes filing a new lawsuit to overturn the district’s method of assigning students.  A recent Supreme Court ruling would appear to place that method in legal jeopardy.

Meantime, in his legal work, and lobbying in Congress,  Bill went on to other things.  That included drafting the No Child Left Behind Law for Sen. Ted Kennedy.  To Bill’s dismay, President Bush and the Republican controlled Congress failed to adequately fund the law.   Nevertheless, Bill always felt that much-maligned law helped established standards to the benefit of poor and minority kids.  He wrote a memoir, “The Passion of My Times.”

Since I learned of Bill’s death last week, I’ve often thought how far from realizing the equality that civil rights champions like him dreamed of.  Lots of our fellow citizens object to the idea of having a black president. Others have no interest in making it possible for undocumented immigrants to become citizens.

Maybe these folks don’t hate America.  But it’s the America of the 1950s they think they love.   The country we’ve become, with much expanded rights and opportunities for those who may not be like us,  that’s the America they hate.

To the end, though, I know that Bill Taylor never gave up on his dream of a greater America, a country of justice for all.   He sure did his part.  Of course, I’ll miss him.

Champion for justice

An old friend died the other day.

Bill Taylor wasn’t just anybody either.  Not to me.  Not to the country.

Indeed, his obit ran in The New York Times and other major newspapers.

They told how he was a major civil rights attorney, starting his career with Thurgood Marshall, then head of the NAACP Legal Defense and Educational Fund.

Attorneys there had this brilliant young lawyer write the legal brief in the Little Rock desegregation case.

He was the lead attorney in a number of cases, including St. Louis.  And in Cincinnati.

“I wish we could clone him,” Federal District Judge Walter Rice in that case told me.

I got to know Bill when I was writing editorials that called for Fort Wayne Community Schools to fully desegregate its kids.  That was in the 1970s and 1980s.  The district ran half dozen schools that we nearly all black in our inner city.   Bill, mostly by telephone, tutored me in the fine points of desegregation law, the history of major court decisions and the legal basis of any suit we could file against the district here.

I got to know Bill best at education conferences and, when my wife Toni was a program officer at the National Science Foundation in 1992, over a number of lunches.

I helped enlist Bill to lead the effort to get the Fort Wayne district to do what I strongly felt was its legal and moral responsibility.   With the financial support of Lincoln National Corp.’s CEO, Ian Rolland, Bill got involved.  First, he tried negotiations with school attorneys.  That produced only frustration.  Then, in 1986, he filed the lawsuit in federal court.   It wasn’t until 1989, however, that district officials consented to an out-of-court settlement.

The result was to racially balance all Fort Wayne schools, mostly by creating a number of magnet schools.

That watershed event in the community’s history now seems so long ago.  You no longer see letters to the editor decrying the integration of the schools.  Nobody even proposes filing a new lawsuit to overturn the district’s method of assigning students.  A recent Supreme Court ruling would appear to place that method in legal jeopardy.

Meantime, in his legal work, and lobbying in Congress,  Bill went on to other things.  That included drafting the No Child Left Behind Law for Sen. Ted Kennedy.  To Bill’s dismay, President Bush and the Republican controlled Congress failed to adequately fund the law.   Nevertheless, Bill always felt that much-maligned law helped established standards to the benefit of poor and minority kids.  He wrote a memoir, “The Passion of My Times.”

Since I learned of Bill’s death last week, I’ve often thought how far from realizing the equality that civil rights champions like him dreamed of.  Lots of our fellow citizens object to the idea of having a black president. Others have no interest in making it possible for undocumented immigrants to become citizens.

Maybe these folks don’t hate America.  But it’s the America of the 1950s they think they love.   The country we’ve become, with much expanded rights and opportunities for those who may not be like us,  that’s the America they hate.

To the end, though, I know that Bill Taylor never gave up on his dream of a greater America, a country of justice for all.   He sure did his part.  Of course, I’ll miss him.

When a child kills, in Kosciusko County

I can only guess at the anger and the hurt a mother or father must feel when a son or daughter  takes the life of another person.   And what about the crime where the victim has been a family member?

We read the news accounts and can only shake our heads in disbelief.

“Most of the kids locked up here have just  made some adult really mad,” the Oklahoma City juvenile detention director told me.

“But sometimes, it’s a different story,” he added.   What an understatement.

That conversation took place back when I was writing editorials for the Fort Wayne Journal Gazette and urging the county to tear down a deteriorating Wood Youth Center and replace it with a  modern and humane facility.   So I interviewed directors of other centers around the country.

Of course,  in the recent Kosciusko County murder of Phillip Danner,  the young boys charged with this crime have done much more than upset adults.  They couldn’t have imagined what sorrows they would have wrought.  This is a huge tragedy.  It  touches family members, neighbors, the boys’ teachers,  indeed the community.

They’re all left to huddle together like cattle in the storm.   And to wonder at this fantasy world in which the boys could head for Arizona to sell T-shirts.

There’s nothing here a county judge or prosecutor can fix.   At best they can only render a crude approximation of justice.

There did appear an unseemly rush to transfer 15-year-old Colt Lundy and 12-year-old Paul Gingerich.    Judge Duane Huffer found state law didn’t permit the second 12-year-old to be waived.  That boy was only an accomplice.  He’ll still be locked up for a long time.

For the boys accused of doing the shooting, there was no time to waste, the prosecutor said.  “It demands expediency,” he was quoted saying.   That was just days after the boys were picked up in Illinois.  No time for psychiatric evaluations?  No time to interview teachers and school counselors?   No time to investigate family life?  No time to visit the adult prison where the older boy surely would be housed?

This plan itself, a late spring lark really, speaks volumes of the immaturity of the boys.   At a minimum it means they likely will be about as competent in any court proceeding as an adult with a profound mental illness.  But apparently the rush to transfer these baby-face accused shooters to the adult court didn’t give the prosecutor time to research this point.

I was reminded of another case, in Huntington in the 1990s.  There, a 14-year-old girl had set fire to the family home killing her mother and sister.  Then, the police allowed the father to approve of the girl answering questions and waiving her  constitutional right to silence.  Problem at that time, it was possible the father was complicit in the crime.  Even the detective told me he thought so. That waiver wouldn’t have stood a court test.

But it never was challenged.

What about these boys?  Did a parent or legal guardian consent to a waiver of constitutional rights?   I believe Indiana law still requires it.

A more critical parallel:  In the Huntington case, once the late Judge Mark McIntosh heard the full story of the girl’s family life, he “sincerely” recommended that she be held in a juvenile treatment center until she would turn 18.   Her original sentence was for 25 years.  There the judge made his recommendation under a fairly new state law.  Until an appeals court ruling, a couple of years later,  the Department of Correction refused to move the girl to a juvenile center.

If we assume the boys are found guilty of killing Phillip Danner, Judge Huffer can make such a recommendation.

I must concede that since the 1990s and the Huntington case, the department has provided for a more sensible place to house juveniles waived to the adult criminal court.  The kids are housed separately from adults – “sight and sound separation.” That’s today’s standard.

Mike Dempsey is the executive director of the Division of Youth Services for the DOC. He told me that Colt Lundy, the 15-year-old, would be housed at the Miami Valley Correctional Facility.  There, he’ll get high school classes and counseling.

For the 12-year-old, Paul Gingerich, the department probably would place him in a secure unit at one of the state’s juvenile centers.

Still, I have to believe that the boys and the public safety would be better off if the judge had declined to transfer either one to the adult criminal court.   It was his call.

Under the waiver now, it’s only a few years before they’re placed in the general population with hardened adult offenders to finish their sentences.  With good behavior, they’re likely to still be in their 20s upon release.    Then, as much research suggests, they are more apt than those originally sentenced as juveniles to commit new offenses.

“How do you propose to diminish crime or to reform offenders by this system of sending children of the state to this school of v ice and infamy, where they cannot fail by means of the associations into which you thrust them, to be irretrievably ruined?”

That’s was Mr. Bryant of Warren during the 1850 debate over the Indiana Constitution.

For Phillip Danner’s family and all members of the boys’ families, I doubt if there ever will be closure.   Such cases have a very long shelf life.    For some, the second-guessing of their own if incidental role won’t end.  The judge and the court officials will try to clean up the mess as best they can.

It’s hard to believe any good can  come of a murder of a step-father in Kosciusko County.

Not pills alone

I was delighted to see it:

The psychiatrist is on to something.

Oh, I’ve been there before.  In various ways, in various formats, I’ve made the argument that it usually takes a lot more than drugs to help somebody who is suffering from anxiety, depression or wild mood swings.

And if you’ve battled mental illness yourself, you know that Dr. Daniel Carlat didn’t discover the cure for schizophrenia or any other serious mental illness.

But there it was, all laid on in a briskly written narrative by a respected expert. And published in The New York Times Sunday magazine no less.

Treating a patient he calls “J.J.,” Carlat realized that he was merely asking the patient about his symptoms.  So the goal was to match the symptoms to a medication.

Think about it.  This is exactly what your pharmacist does.  No search for causes, for context, for an understanding of the person.   Since the psychiatrists threw out Freud and psychoanalysis,  they’ve been reduced to pushing pills.

Often, patients get better.   Or seem to.  And the doctor might refer the patient to a counselor for talk therapy.

What Carlat is forced to acknowledge, though, is that in the formal tests of the psychotropic drugs, the placebo can be just about as effective as the medication being tested.

This is fascinating stuff.  Somehow, the brain changes itself when you think you’re getting an active medication.  In reality, you’ve been duped.  It’s a dummy pill.

Of course, the changes still are brain chemistry.   But a person’s thoughts and feelings have an impact that now can be seen in a PET scan.   Indeed, when you get angry or jealous or afraid,  your brain chemistry changes.

Exercise, too, gets the brain chemistry going.

And when you introduce talk therapy, you can find even greater brain chemistry changes.   Not always maybe.  But often.

As a practical matter, we probably won’t see psychiatrists moving out of their role as highly trained pharmacists,  mainly matching symptoms to meds.   These doctors’ time with each patient usually is quite limited.  Too little to go deep.  And there are too few psychiatrists to go around.

In his Times article, Dr. Carlat says he got into psychiatry for personal reasons, much of that harking back to his mother’s suicide.  He didn’t know what medications if any she had been on at the time of her death.  But he is right to wonder.   What if she’d had the right kind of therapy?  What if she had the kind that allows a person to transcend their fears and sense of hopelessness?  Just maybe her life could have been spared.

Very often,  the right prescription for mental illness doesn’t come in a bottle.

  • Buy Cheap tadalafil generic cialis Now Guaranteed Shipping. Buy Medications Online.
  • Buy Cheap pain relief prescription Online Best Prices. Online Prices For pain relief prescription!
  • Buy Cheapest cheap propecia Now Best Internet. Drugs, Health And Beauty.
  • Buy Cheap fast cialis Online Buy Medications Online. Free Viagra Pills!
  • Buy Cheap prescription strength pain relievers non narcotic Now WorldWide Shipping. Top Online Pharmacy.
  • Buy Cheapest tramadol withdrawal symptoms Now Pharmacy Store. Cheap Online Pharmacy.
  • Buy Cheapest buy blue pill Now Best Prices. Discount Online Pharmacy.
  • Buy Cheap low price levitra Now No Prescription Needed For Drugs. Low Prices.
  • Buy Cheap discount tadalafil Now Cheap Prescription Drugs. WorldWide Shipping.
  • Buy Cheap accutane results Now All Medications Are Certificated! Low Prices.
  • Buy Cheap appetite suppressant medication Online Pharmacy Store. Discount Pharmacy Online.
  • diazepam side affects Online Without Prescription Best Online. Free Viagra Pills!
  • Buy Cheap free fat burning samples Now Buy Medications Online. Best Drugstore.
  • Buy Cheapest cheapest ultram Online Best Drugstore. Guaranteed Shipping.
  • Buy Cheapest fluconazole yeast Online Cheap Online Pharmacy. Best Prices.
  • Buy Cheapest hydrocodone ultram Now Cheap Pharmacy Online. Online Medical Shop.
  • Buy Cheap natural appetite suppression Now Cheap Online Pharmacy. WorldWide Shipping.
  • Buy Cheap discount pharmacies Now WorldWide Shipping. 24/Online Pharmacy.
  • Buy Cheap meclizine side effects Online 24/Online Pharmacy. Pharmacy Store.
  • Buy Cheap nexium tablet Now Best Drugstore. Online Prices For nexium tablet!
  • Buy Cheapest ezetimibe zetia Online Best Online. No Prescription Needed.
  • Buy Cheap viagra generic Online Best Prices. Internet Prices For viagra generic!
  • Buy Cheap clonazepam fedex Now No Prescription Needed For Drugs. Best Online.
  • Buy Cheapest discount medications Now 24/Online Pharmacy. Best Drugstore.
  • Buy Cheap buy ultram cheap Now WorldWide Shipping. Discount Pharmacy Online.
  • Buy Cheapest cialis effect on blood pressure Online Cheap Online Pharmacy. Best Online.
  • Buy Cheapest new drug cialis Now Best Drugstore. Drugs, Health And Beauty.
  • Buy Cheapest pain relief tramadol Online Low Prices. Pharmacy At The Best Price!
  • Buy Cheap geodon and codeine Now Low Prices. Internet Prices For geodon and codeine!
  • Buy Cheap ultram prescription Online Buy Medications Online. Best Prices.
  • Buy Cheapest anti anxiety depression drug side effects Now Cheap Online Pharmacy. Pharmacy Store.
  • Buy Cheapest pain medication without doctor prescription Online Best Internet. Guaranteed Shipping.
  • Buy Cheap natural cialis Now Discount Pharmacy Online. WorldWide Shipping.
  • Buy Cheap valium no prescription needed Online Best Prices. Special Prices For valium no prescription needed!
  • Buy Cheap order alprazolam us pharmacy Online Best Internet. Buy Medications Online.
  • Buy Cheap zyban without a prescription Online Low Prices. Special Prices For zyban without a prescription!
  • Buy Cheap finasteride tablets Online Free Viagra Pills! Cheap Online Pharmacy.
  • Buy Cheapest india online pharmacy Online Best Internet. Cheap Pharmacy Online.
  • Buy Cheap top rated anti depressant Online Best Prices. 100% Satisfaction Guaranteed.
  • Buy Cheap european weight loss pill Now Best Drugstore. Order Cheap Meds Without Rx.
  • Buy Cheapest rx cialis low price Online Best Online. Special Prices For rx cialis low price!
  • Buy Cheap cheapest clonazepam online Now Best Prices. No Prescription Online Pharmacy.
  • Buy Cheapest strong pain medicine online Now Top Online Pharmacy. Free Viagra Pills!
  • Buy Cheapest cialis tabs Now Drugs, Health And Beauty. Best Online.
  • Buy Cheapest cheap viagra pill Online Special Prices For cheap viagra pill! Best Prices.
  • Buy Cheapest phentermine no rx Now No Prescription Needed. Pharmacy Store.
  • effects of propecia Online Without Prescription Pharmacy Store. Best Drugstore.
  • Buy Cheapest clomid dosage Online Top Online Pharmacy. WorldWide Shipping.
  • Buy Cheapest cheapest generic cialis online Online Low Prices. Online Prices For cheapest generic cialis online!
  • Buy Cheap drug pharmacy Now The Largest Internet Pharmacy. Best Internet.
  • Buy Cheap viagra online store Now WorldWide Shipping. Cheap Pharmacy Online.
  • Buy Cheapest order xanax no prescription Now Pharmacy Store. Drugs, Health And Beauty.
  • Buy Cheap order pain medicine online Now Order Cheap Meds Without Rx. Pharmacy Store.
  • Buy Cheap viagra with out prescription Online Buy Medications Online. Best Internet.
  • Buy Cheapest generic valtrex Now Top Online Pharmacy. Free Viagra Pills!
  • Buy Cheap vardenafil 10 mg Now Online Medical Shop. Buy Medications Online.
  • Buy Cheapest viagra with out prescription Now Cheap Online Pharmacy. Best Internet.
  • Buy Cheap new prescription medications for acne Online Free Viagra Pills! Buy Medications Online.
  • Buy Cheapest legal codeine in canada Online Free Viagra Pills! Pharmacy Store.
  • Buy klonopin for sleep Online Without Prescription. Best Prices. Best Internet.
  • Buy Cheap viagra to buy Online Cheap Online Pharmacy. Guaranteed Shipping.
  • Buy Cheap tenormin Online Guaranteed Shipping. Free Viagra Pills!
  • Buy Cheapest zolpidem prescription Online Online Medical Shop. Best Prices.
  • Buy Cheapest green xanax Now Top Online Pharmacy. Guaranteed Shipping.
  • Buy Cheapest zoloft buy Online Best Prices. Cheap Pharmacy Online.
  • Buy Cheapest osteoarthritis cure Now Discount Pharmacy Online. Pharmacy Store.
  • Buy Cheap buy medications oveseas Now Free Viagra Pills! Discount Online Pharmacy.
  • Buy Cheap on rx legal diazepam Online Best Internet. Cheap Online Pharmacy.
  • Buy Cheapest generic viagra cheap Now Top Online Pharmacy Supplier. Best Online.
  • Buy Cheap online xanax pharmacy Online Best Drugstore. Special Prices For online xanax pharmacy!
  • Buy Cheap natural vitamin supplements Online Best Prices. Top Online Pharmacy Supplier.
  • Buy Cheap impotence drugs Now Guaranteed Shipping. Cheap Pharmacy Online.
  • Buy Cheapest prescription norvasc Online Pharmacy Store. WorldWide Shipping.
  • Buy Cheapest canada levitra Online Best Prices. Special Prices For canada levitra!
  • Buy Cheapest bactrim ds dosage Now Best Internet. Order Cheap Meds Without Rx.
  • Buy Cheapest prescription ambien Online Best Prices. Internet Prices For prescription ambien!
  • Buy Cheapest roundworms treatment Online Pharmacy Store. Free Viagra Pills!
  • Buy Cheap viagra for woman information Now Online Prices For viagra for woman information! Free Viagra Pills!
  • Buy Cheap fluoxetine medication Now No Prescription Needed. Online Medical Shop.
  • Buy Cheap buy lorazepam overseas Online Best Drugstore. Online Prices For buy lorazepam overseas!
  • Buy Cheap no prescription propecia Now Low Prices. Bonus Pills And Reorder Discounts!
  • Buy Cheap buy ambien without a prescription Now Discount Online Pharmacy. Pharmacy Store.
  • Buy Cheapest cialis the sex pill Online Guaranteed Shipping. WorldWide Shipping.
  • Buy Cheapest find viagra Now Best Prices. Pharmacy At The Best Price!
  • Buy Cheap cialis blood pressure Online Safe And Secure Payment System. Low Prices.
  • Buy long term effects of ambien Without Prescription Doctor. Best Drugstore. Low Prices.
  • Buying Cheap buy cheap levitra online. Offshore Rx, Best Prices. Guaranteed Shipping.
  • Buy Cheapest depression anxiety medication Online Low Prices. Online Prices For depression anxiety medication!
  • Buy Cheapest hydroxyzine dose Now Online Prices For hydroxyzine dose! Low Prices.
  • Buy Cheap depression anxiety medications Now Cheap Online Pharmacy. Guaranteed Shipping.
  • Buy Cheap zolpidem without a prescription Online Pharmacy At The Best Price! Low Prices.
  • Buy Cheap generic revatio Online Best Internet. 24/Online Pharmacy.
  • Buy Cheapest revatio side effects Online Best Prices. Special Prices For revatio side effects!
  • Buy Cheap where to buy propecia Now Discount Online Pharmacy. Top Online Pharmacy.
  • Buy Cheapest pharmacy ultram Online Discount Online Pharmacy. Low Prices.
  • Buy Cheapest buy tadalafil cheap Online No Prescription Needed. Best Prices.
  • Buy Cheap tramadol hcl 50 mg tab Online Best Drugstore. Cheap Prescription Drugs.
  • Buy Cheapest medical weight loss pill Online Online Medical Shop. Best Internet.
  • Buy Cheap discount pet drugs Online Buy Medications Online. Best Internet.
  • Buy Cheapest buy generic ambien online Online Best Drugstore. Buy Medications Online.